Victor Cha: Trump's words are 'classic condominium of power' talk
CSIS adviser says joint statement echoes China and Russia's revisionist goals; Trump appears receptive
Analyst warns friction with US allies will grow if trilateral statement is enforced
The first-ever trilateral summit among the United States, China and Russia — held Thursday (local time) on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum in Shenzhen, China — may signal the emergence of a great-power "condominium of power," analysts said. Such an arrangement could prove deeply alarming for US allies and partners, including South Korea.
Victor Cha, Korea Chair at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, said on a CSIS podcast that day that Donald Trump had made remarks to the effect that "if we all agree, there will be no problems in the world," calling it "a classic condominium of power statement."
Earlier, at a bilateral summit with Chinese President Xi Jinping, Trump had told Xi, "As long as you and I are in charge, we will have no problems."
Cha said Trump had also mentioned the possibility of another such gathering, noting that Trump invited Russian President Vladimir Putin to the Group of 20 summit to be held in the United States in December. "From the perspective of allies and partners, they will be very concerned about this," Cha said.
He added that it would be "a problem" if Trump said nothing to Xi about China's economic coercion against Japan and nothing to Putin about violations of Japan's air defense identification zone. "For allies, a great-power condominium is the worst-case scenario imaginable," Cha said.
Cha also noted that the joint statement issued after the trilateral summit made no mention of Iran, Ukraine or North Korea — an omission he said was "just as important as the four items that were included," adding that it signaled the three leaders had failed to reach agreement on those issues.
Sid Seiler, a senior adviser at CSIS, said concerns were already being voiced in South Korea about what a trilateral condominium resembling the Yalta system might look like in practice. "I think similar concerns will emerge among European countries as well," he said.
Seiler added that the idea of Trump using his personal relationships with Putin and Xi to placate Russia and China "continues to be a source of concern for many observers, not only in the United States but abroad."
On the joint statement from the trilateral meeting, Seiler said the tone, language and positions of the four items "closely mirror the consistent messaging of Russia and China — their vision for the world and their revisionist goals of changing the international order." He said this gave the impression that Trump "is not an advocate or defender of the current order, but rather someone who is receptive to changing it."
Seiler said the items were abstract enough to be relatively safe for now, but warned that "if stronger efforts are made to apply and implement them, the friction with our allies will be much greater."
mokiya@heraldcorp.com
