National Assembly Research Service report asks: are current designation criteria enough?

'Korean physician maldistribution index' urged to objectively identify doctor-shortage areas

Doctors [Yonhap]
Doctors [Yonhap]

A significant number of areas designated as medically underserved are still not receiving the government support they are supposed to qualify for, a new report has found.

According to a National Assembly Research Service report released Thursday — titled "Are Current Designation Criteria Sufficient for Medically Underserved Areas? Redesigning Designation Criteria with Linkage Between Vulnerability Assessment and Support Systems in Mind" — 18 of 22 areas designated as pediatric underserved zones, all 11 areas designated as artificial kidney unit underserved zones, and 49 of 108 areas designated as obstetric underserved zones are receiving no relevant government support as of 2026. That amounts to 78 of 141 designated cases, or 55.3 percent.

The report said the current designation system for medically underserved areas operates under different criteria depending on the law and policy objective involved, leaving it poorly equipped to distinguish the degree and causes of vulnerability across regions.

The Public Health and Medical Services Act allows the government to designate and publicly announce medically underserved areas based on assessments of healthcare utilization, supply conditions and accessibility. However, the Emergency Medical Services Act and the Community Health Act also reference underserved medical areas, meaning the definitions and designation frameworks are not applied consistently across laws.

The current assessment process focuses primarily on accessibility and utilization conditions for individual medical services. As a result, even areas that receive the same underserved designation can differ significantly in travel time to care, service utilization rates and healthcare workforce supply — differences that are not adequately reflected in the designation outcome.

Particularly absent is any standard for separately designating doctor-shortage areas based on a comprehensive assessment of physician supply and medical demand by region. The report said an objective evaluation framework that can inform physician training and placement policy is urgently needed.

Existing support projects are generally carried out by soliciting and selecting healthcare institutions in designated areas and providing funding for facilities, equipment and operating costs. In practice, however, some areas have gone without support because no institutions applied or because applicants submitted inadequate project plans.

In response, the report recommended reorganizing the evaluation criteria and the management and utilization of designation outcomes under Article 12 of the Public Health and Medical Services Act to ensure consistency and legal coherence across statutes. It also proposed introducing a "Korean Physician Uneven Distribution index" — tentatively named K-PUD — along with improvements to the medical vulnerability assessment framework, to enable objective designation of doctor-shortage areas and their use in workforce policy.

The report further proposed prioritizing the strengthening of existing healthcare institutions' clinical capacity, while exploring cooperation with neighboring facilities and mobile or circuit-based medical services in areas where securing a project-implementing institution is difficult. It also called for evaluating support outcomes based primarily on improvements in residents' access to healthcare.


thlee@heraldcorp.com