Gangnam-gu allocates 45.3% of its budget to welfare; Gangseo-gu allocates 68.6% — a gap of 23.3 percentage points
Gangseo-gu's welfare and health budget of 1.08 trillion won exceeds Gangnam-gu's by 406.5 billion won, reflecting stark differences in fiscal structure
Seoul's Gangnam-gu and Gangseo-gu are both large autonomous districts with populations of between 540,000 and 550,000. Despite their similar size and overall budgets of around 1.5 trillion won ($1.13 billion), the two districts show a striking divergence in how much of their 2027 budget proposals they devote to welfare.
Gangnam-gu allocates 45.3% of its total budget to welfare, while Gangseo-gu directs 68.6% to welfare and health combined — a gap of 23.3 percentage points.
Gangnam-gu's population stands at 551,245 and Gangseo-gu's at 547,816, a difference of just 3,429 people. Among Seoul's 25 autonomous districts, Songpa-gu has the largest population at 640,651, followed by Gangnam-gu, Gangseo-gu, Gangdong-gu (497,412) and Nowon-gu (478,638).
The two districts may be nearly identical in population, but their budget structures tell a very different story.
Gangnam-gu's 2027 budget proposal totals 1.49 trillion won, of which 676.5 billion won — about 45.3% — goes to welfare.
Gangseo-gu, by contrast, has allocated 1.08 trillion won of its 1.58 trillion won budget proposal to welfare and health, accounting for about 68.6% of the total.
Put another way, for every 1 billion won Gangseo-gu spends, about 686 million won goes to welfare and health. For Gangnam-gu, the equivalent figure is about 453 million won.
The gap in absolute welfare spending is also substantial. Gangseo-gu's welfare and health budget exceeds Gangnam-gu's welfare budget by about 406.5 billion won. While Gangseo-gu's overall budget is only about 85.6 billion won larger than Gangnam-gu's, the welfare spending gap is far wider.
After setting aside welfare and health, Gangseo-gu has about 496.1 billion won left for other areas. Gangnam-gu, by comparison, has about 817 billion won available for non-welfare spending — roughly 320.9 billion won more than Gangseo-gu.
The higher welfare share in Gangseo-gu is attributed to differences in local welfare demand and demographic composition, including the fact that it has about 30,000 more households than Gangnam-gu. This illustrates why raw population figures alone do not tell the full story when comparing welfare budgets.
A high welfare budget share does not in itself signal a fiscal problem. Programs covering basic livelihood support, elderly and disability services, and child care and early education carry significant legally mandated and central- and city-government subsidy obligations, leaving districts with limited room to adjust spending on their own. The size of the welfare-eligible population, income levels and the degree of aging in each district also shape budget structures.
However, with 68.6% of its budget committed to welfare and health, Gangseo-gu has structurally less room to fund local development, education and culture, economic revitalization, and infrastructure such as roads and public facilities. Securing adequate resources for local initiatives while meeting welfare demand — and improving overall fiscal efficiency — is emerging as a key challenge for the district.
Gangnam-gu faces its own balancing act: with 45.3% of its budget going to welfare, it must simultaneously pursue improvements in residents' well-being, urban infrastructure and future growth projects.
The comparison between the two districts shows that even Seoul autonomous districts of similar size can see dramatically different budget allocations depending on welfare demand and fiscal structure.
For districts where welfare spending approaches 70 percent of the total budget, analysts say it is worth examining both the long-term sustainability of that spending and the remaining capacity to invest in other policy areas.
seouldream01@heraldcorp.com
