Broadcaster Choi Dong-seok, a former announcer, has denied defamation charges after being referred to prosecutors for posting malicious comments about his ex-wife Park Ji-yoon, acknowledging he wrote the posts but insisting they contained no false information.
Choi's legal team recently submitted a written opinion to the Seoul Northern District Prosecutors' Office making that argument.
Choi was recently referred to prosecutors with a recommendation for indictment on charges of defamation under the Act on Promotion of Information and Communications Network Utilization and Information Protection for posting disparaging content about Park in online communities. The comments he wrote included: "Park Ji-yoon is the pathetic one. Everyone who needs to know already knows — she got caught watching porn with her boyfriend, hired a bodyguard to kick the kids' father, and that's just the start"; "Issues with men, extravagance, badmouthing her in-laws and husband, violence and verbal abuse toward her daughter — there's no shortage of examples"; and "Looks like you're a friend of Park Ji-yoon's, but isn't sleeping at her boyfriend's place and watching porn together a separate issue?"
According to Star News on Friday, Choi's team argued in the opinion submitted to the prosecutors' office that the claim about Park sleeping at a male acquaintance's home and watching porn together during their marriage contained no false information.
Choi's team cited as grounds a ruling handed down by Jeju District Court on Monday. The lawsuit was filed by Choi against Park's male acquaintance, identified only as A, and the court partially accepted Choi's claims, ordering A to pay Choi 30 million won ($22,500) in damages. The court specifically identified as misconduct the fact that Park had watched "365 Days" with A in the same room, both in sleepwear, during a trip to the United States. The ruling also noted that when a mutual acquaintance asked the two what genre the film was, they answered "porn."
Choi's team therefore argued that because the comments reflected facts recognized by a court, they could not constitute false information.
The team further argued that the purpose of the comments was not to defame Park but to exercise "the minimum right to explain and rebut" in response to what it described as Park's unfair attacks — including portraying Choi as delusionally jealous and incompetent.
Choi's team also said Park "used broadcasting and social media to cultivate an image as a working mother devoted to her career, child-rearing and family life, and on that basis appeared on terrestrial television while also running group-purchase ventures worth hundreds of millions to tens of billions of won, wielding strong influence over the public." It added that "it is clearly a matter of public interest to allow viewers and consumers to learn the accurate facts and to verify and critique whether her public image corresponds to the truth, and whether it is appropriate for her to continue broadcasting activities and commercial group purchases on the basis of that image."
The two were classmates in the 30th cohort of KBS announcers and married in 2009, having a son and a daughter together. Their relationship began to fracture in 2023, and they are currently in divorce proceedings.
Park and Choi each filed alienation-of-affection suits against the other, alleging infidelity, but a first-instance court rejected both claims. Park dropped her appeal, while Choi appealed against A; the appellate court reversed the lower ruling and found that Park and A had engaged in misconduct. Park has denied the misconduct, saying A is a gay person she has known for a long time and that there were no romantic feelings between them.
paq@heraldcorp.com
