Association surveyed 2,000 of its member stores on fees

Over 98% of those surveyed exceed 3 billion won in annual sales

'Fees vary by sales volume — simple average is questionable'

Regional branches pursuing contract terminations, no formal notice yet

The Korea Mart Association on Wednesday called for a cap on BC Card's merchant fee rates, which it said were the highest in the industry, and demanded that representative industry groups be given negotiating rights over fees. [Korea Federation of SMEs]
The Korea Mart Association on Wednesday called for a cap on BC Card's merchant fee rates, which it said were the highest in the industry, and demanded that representative industry groups be given negotiating rights over fees. [Korea Federation of SMEs]

The Korea Mart Association and BC Card are at odds over merchant fee rates, with the association threatening to halt BC Card payments at its member stores while BC Card rebuffed the claim. The dispute has centered on the association's figure of an average fee rate of 2.13%, drawn from a survey of 2,000 of its roughly 6,000 member stores, raising questions about the survey's scope and methodology.

The association on Wednesday demanded that BC Card lower its average merchant fee rate of 2.13%, which it said was higher than those of other card companies, which ranged from 1.94 to 2.04%. The association said it would suspend BC Card payments at member stores starting in January if the demand was not met.

The 2.13% figure was derived from a survey of 2,000 stores out of the association's roughly 6,000 members. More than 98% of those surveyed were standard merchants with annual sales exceeding 3 billion won ($2.25 million), with sales volumes distributed between 3 billion and 30 billion won. The remainder were small and mid-sized merchants eligible for preferential fee rates.

According to Small Enterprise and Market Service data on commercial establishments, there were 63,862 supermarkets nationwide as of June. The 2,000 stores surveyed by the association represent about 3.1% of that total by simple store count. Because the sampling method and each store's share of sales volume have not been disclosed, however, it is difficult to determine whether the survey results are representative of the association's full membership or of the broader supermarket sector nationwide.

Merchant fee rates vary depending on annual sales volume and transaction costs. Small and mid-sized merchants with annual sales of 3 billion won or less are subject to preferential credit card fee rates of 0.4 to 1.45%. Standard merchants above that threshold have their rates set individually by card companies based on eligible costs and other factors. The composition of the surveyed stores by sales volume could therefore significantly affect the calculated average fee rate.

The core problem is that neither the sales breakdown of the 2,000 surveyed stores nor the methodology used to calculate the fee rate has been made public, making it difficult for BC Card to produce a comparable average on the same basis as the association's 2.13% figure. BC Card said its fee rates for mart merchants were the lowest in the industry and that all merchants with annual sales of 3 billion won or less were receiving preferential rates.

Meanwhile, the association has also criticized the card industry more broadly for applying fee rates above 2% to standard merchants. A card industry official said it was unclear what criteria the association used to calculate the per-company fee rates it presented, and questioned whether averaging fee rates across merchants with different sales volumes could fairly represent the position of the entire mart sector.

The two sides also disagree over who holds negotiating rights on fee rates. The association argues that individual merchants have no right to negotiate and are left with no choice but to accept whatever rate a card company sets. BC Card rebuffed that position, saying negotiations are conducted with individual merchants, not the association, and that it responds to all requests for consultations from merchants.

The association is also pursuing contract terminations with BC Card through its regional branches. An association official said the branches were moving ahead with terminations and that a related announcement was expected soon. BC Card, however, said it had not received any actual termination notices from individual merchants as of Friday.


snsd@heraldcorp.com