Kim Soo-hyun (left) and Kim Se-ui [Newsis]
Kim Soo-hyun (left) and Kim Se-ui [Newsis]

A court has ordered actor Kim Soo-hyun's agency to pay 870 million won ($654,000) to advertisers over a personal life controversy, marking the agency's second consecutive courtroom defeat. The ruling follows a separate decision last week requiring the agency to return 1.15 billion won to health supplement company From Bio.

According to legal sources, Seoul Central District Court's Civil Division 25, presided over by Chief Judge Kwon Ki-man, ruled partly in favor of the plaintiffs in a damages lawsuit worth more than 2 billion won filed by Cuckoo Group affiliates Cuckoo Electronics and Cuckoo Homesys against Kim and his agency, Gold Medalist.

The court ordered Gold Medalist to pay about 260 million won to Cuckoo Electronics and about 610 million won to Cuckoo Homesys, for a combined total of roughly 870 million won. The court found that some advertising contracts had been validly terminated due to a breach of the dignity-maintenance obligation, while others were terminated because the relationship of trust between the parties had broken down, requiring the agency to return a portion of the modeling fees.

However, the court did not find Kim personally liable for damages.

Kim had served as an exclusive model for Cuckoo Electronics for more than a decade. Early last year, allegations emerged that the late Kim Sae-ron had been in a relationship with Kim since she was a minor, prompting a public backlash. Cuckoo Electronics pulled Kim's advertisements and filed a civil lawsuit.

The case took a turn when a police investigation found that the allegations of a relationship with a minor had been fabricated. The voice recordings and KakaoTalk messages that had formed the basis of the allegations were found to have been doctored. Kim Se-ui, the head of the YouTube channel Garosero Research Institute that had raised the allegations, was subsequently indicted and is currently standing trial.

Kim is also involved in litigation with several other companies, including From Bio, Trendmaker, Classys, Eider and Mido, with the total amount in dispute reportedly reaching 10 billion won. Earlier, a court dismissed in full a claim by watch brand Mido against Gold Medalist seeking the return of 570 million won in contract fees. A lawsuit filed by Eider was settled through court-recommended mediation that reduced a 2.5 billion won damages claim to the return of roughly 400 million won in remaining modeling fees. On Nov. 13, however, a court ruled that Kim's side must return 1.15 billion won in modeling fees to From Bio.

Kim has also filed a 30 billion won damages lawsuit against Kim Se-ui, alleging financial losses caused by the spread of false information.


paq@heraldcorp.com