Earnings forecasts seen falling sharply when memory prices drop
Analyst sees oversupply by year-end, warns long-term investors against buying
The analyst who shocked investors roughly two months ago by setting fair-value targets of 70,000 won ($53) for Samsung Electronics and 200,000 won for SK hynix has issued a fresh warning: if memory chip prices begin falling in early next year, share prices will drop far more sharply than they already have.
Appearing on the YouTube channel "Jisik Hankkut" on Wednesday, the analyst held to those targets — 70,000 won for Samsung Electronics and 200,000 won for SK hynix — and said the real collapse had not yet begun.
"A full-scale crash in memory chipmakers' share prices only happens once memory prices start falling, and we're not there yet," the analyst said. "When news breaks at the end of this year or early next year that memory prices have actually declined, securities firms will rush to slash their earnings forecasts for memory companies for next year and the year after."
The analyst added that while companies speak of selling out their entire output, utilization rates stand at around 70 percent. "If utilization hits 100 percent, that means 30 percent of what's being made is going into inventory," the analyst said. "From next year or the year after, they will have no choice but to raise that remaining 30 percent of utilization — otherwise China will take everything. Ultimately, a price decline is inevitable."
The analyst said the memory cycle appeared to have already peaked in the third quarter of this year and forecast that operating profit margins at the three major memory makers would narrow in the fourth quarter and in the first quarter of next year. The argument is that current strong earnings and share prices reflect rising memory prices rather than higher output, making the price rally unsustainable once supply increases.
Asked whether investors should continue holding Samsung Electronics, SK hynix and Nvidia, the analyst said short-term traders could exploit volatility for opportunities, but warned that long-term investors with a horizon of a year or more should not buy at all. "It will fall well below the price you paid," the analyst said.
However, the analyst added that the exact timing and pace of any decline would be difficult to predict, as it depends on how memory prices move.
"Looking at past cycles, memory prices have fallen 50 percent within a year of starting to decline and about 90 percent within two years," the analyst said, doubling down on the view that a full-blown oversupply would trigger a sustained price drop.
The analyst noted that even if Samsung Electronics and SK hynix held production steady, output was rising because of Micron and Chinese producers, and forecast that the market would tip into oversupply by the end of this year.
The analyst advised South Korea's two semiconductor giants that, with oversupply coming from next year anyway, they should channel most of their cash into research and development and pursue mergers and acquisitions with companies that have strong design capabilities. The underlying view is that leadership in the AI industry will likely be decided by software competition rather than a race to produce hardware.
The analyst first drew attention last October, when Samsung Electronics shares had plunged to 210,000 won and SK hynix to 1.26 million won, by setting fair-value targets of 70,000 won and 200,000 won respectively — figures that rattled investors.
At the time, the analyst argued that the share price gains were entirely the product of a price bubble. "Once memory prices start falling soon, earnings will crumble like a sandcastle — and because they are not sustainable, foreign investors have been selling continuously," the analyst said.
Meanwhile, according to Korea Exchange, Samsung Electronics closed Thursday up 1.13 percent at 196,900 won, while SK hynix rose 3.41 percent to 1.183 million won. Both stocks remain sharply below their June peaks — Samsung Electronics is down about 48 percent and SK hynix about 60 percent.
betterj@heraldcorp.com
