A Seoul National University professor has drawn attention by calling on the public not to strip people caught up in scandal of any chance at redemption, following the death of Lee Jin-woo, who had been embroiled in allegations of cheating on the Legal Education Eligibility Test (LEET) and the College Scholastic Ability Test.
Shin Jae-yong, a professor at Seoul National University's business school and author of the book "Fair Compensation," shared his thoughts on the Lee Jin-woo case Thursday on Remember Connect, a professional networking service.
Shin opened by calling Lee's death "truly heartbreaking." He then lamented, "He atoned in his own way through death, yet the public condemns even that last choice," adding, "I was taught to hate the sin but not the sinner."
Shin drew a parallel to the death last year of Kim Min-ji, author of "Wise Parents Keep a Comfortable Distance," who died after becoming embroiled in controversy over alleged fabrications of academic credentials and endorsements from prominent overseas psychologists. "A similar thing has happened again in just over a year," Shin said. Kim had attracted wide attention by citing degrees from Harvard University and UCLA and endorsements from well-known foreign psychologists, but later died after allegations emerged that those credentials and endorsements had been fabricated.
Shin said both individuals had used top-tier academic credentials and test scores — the kind the public covets — as the central selling point of their books. "They became bestselling authors and YouTube celebrities, only to be instantly transformed from 'genius scholar-writers' into 'protagonists of a nationwide fraud' once netizens began fact-checking online," Shin said, "and they were immediately cut off and expelled by publishers, bookstores and hagwon."
"Within just days of fraud and fabrication allegations being widely reported in the media, and as pressure for explanation and verification reached its peak, both were found dead," Shin said. "I hope this does not happen again."
Shin particularly took issue with the tendency of the public and media — who had eagerly consumed and promoted these individuals' credentials — to turn on them and drive them into a corner once allegations surfaced.
"The public, the publishing world, YouTubers and the media, who cheered louder than anyone over their fabricated credentials rather than the actual content of their books and lifted them to the sky, are also the quickest to cut them off once the truth comes out — turning on them mercilessly, like hunting dogs with no way out," Shin said. "I hope we can break this cycle of fabrication, success, downfall and suicide."
Shin was also clear, however, that using false credentials or career histories for personal gain cannot be justified. "Fabricating credentials and academic backgrounds, and gaining personal benefit through fraud and deception, deserves criticism," he said, "but it is not so grave a sin as to warrant dying alone in a motel room."
He added that he hoped people would "be passionate about a creator's content, not their credentials," and that "while wrongdoing should be held to strict account, those who have done wrong should still be left with a path back to life."
He also expressed hope for "a society that neither overvalues a person based on their credentials, nor expands one person's wrongdoing into a wholesale negation of their entire existence," saying, "I hope we never become a society where anyone must pay for their mistakes with their life."
betterj@heraldcorp.com
