FSC considers reflecting at-risk borrower management in bank evaluations

Measure expected to fall under 'governance' category of organizational strategy

Branch offices lack specific KPIs for managing borrowers before delinquency occurs

Overseas lenders already use early-warning systems to offer proactive financial counseling

A bank consultation desk. (Yoon Chang-bin/The Korea Herald)
A bank consultation desk. (Yoon Chang-bin/The Korea Herald)

The government is reviewing whether to add the management of "pre-delinquency borrowers" as an evaluation metric ahead of the rollout of its inclusive finance assessment system. While borrowers who have already fallen into arrears can access debt-relief measures, those at high risk of default but not yet delinquent remain in a blind spot — a gap that regulators say calls for earlier intervention.

According to financial industry sources Thursday, the Financial Services Commission is examining ways to incorporate post-loan management efforts into its evaluation framework as a follow-up to the "Inclusive Finance Comprehensive Evaluation System" it announced last month.

The targets of such post-loan management would be borrowers who have not yet missed payments but whose cash flow — including income — has deteriorated sharply, making future delinquency likely.

Under the envisioned approach, banks would proactively reach out to borrowers showing early warning signs — such as a sharp drop in deposit balances or unpaid utility bills — to offer financial counseling and refer them to suitable policy financing or debt-restructuring programs. The goal is to head off defaults before they occur.

The FSC is expected to incorporate post-loan management criteria into the "governance" subcategory of the organizational and strategy section of the evaluation framework. The current framework already allocates up to 35 percent of the total score to debt restructuring, but that section focuses on borrowers already in arrears — measuring outcomes such as the write-off and sale of delinquent loans. In practice, branch offices, which serve as the first point of contact for post-loan management, have no specific KPIs for handling borrowers before delinquency sets in.

Evaluation likely to assess KPIs, dedicated management units

The detailed indicators under the governance section of the evaluation framework cover the size of dedicated inclusive finance units, whether KPIs reflect inclusive finance goals, and the decision-making authority of relevant departments. Post-loan management efforts are expected to be assessed along similar lines.

Among the options being discussed for banks is adding post-loan management items to branch-level KPIs. However, given the already heavy workload on branch staff, some have also proposed creating separate dedicated units. One approach would involve expanding the head-office credit management departments — which currently handle debt collection, write-offs and loan sales for delinquent borrowers — to also cover pre-delinquency cases.

Some banks are also turning to AI. Woori Bank is building its own post-loan management system as part of the AI transformation initiatives under its Future Co-Growth Project. The plan calls for delivering real-time updates to branch offices on changes in borrowers' risk profiles — drawing on delinquency data held by credit information firms as well as credit rating and registry changes — to enable proactive responses. The bank is also pursuing automation of post-loan management tasks using AI agents.

Still, concerns are surfacing within the banking sector. Some worry that extending support to borrowers who have not yet missed payments could trigger fairness disputes with diligent repayers or invite moral hazard. "We need clear standards on how to prevent moral hazard and how to identify borrowers in genuine distress," an official at one commercial bank said.

Pre-delinquency borrowers a management blind spot — overseas lenders act earlier

Academics have consistently argued that banks devote far more effort to selling loan products than to managing borrowers after disbursement. While the government's recent push for inclusive finance has prompted banks to step up support for vulnerable borrowers, experts say the management framework for borrowers who have not yet fallen into arrears remains inadequate.

Kim Yong-gi, head of the Production and Inclusive Finance Research Society, said borrowers whose cash flow has deteriorated sharply — even without missing payments — can often avoid delinquency if their loan repayment structure is simply adjusted. "Every borrower shows signs of worsening cash flow just before going delinquent, but financial institutions are not paying attention to those signals," Kim said.

According to the delinquency management process at one bank, branch staff respond to a missed payment by initiating debt collection and loan-protection measures while simultaneously informing the borrower of debt-restructuring programs such as the Fresh Start Fund. If repayment still does not resume, the head-office credit management department proceeds with write-off or loan-sale procedures. No separate management manual exists, however, for borrowers who have not yet fallen behind.

"Once delinquency occurs, it counts against our KPIs, so there is some incentive to manage proactively," one commercial bank official said. "But ultimately it is a secondary task — our core business is new lending." Another official noted that supporting pre-delinquency borrowers earns only a minor bonus in the scoring, not a primary metric. "With branch consolidations reducing staff numbers, each employee is now responsible for more borrowers — and the honest truth is we simply do not have the capacity to manage borrowers who have not yet gone delinquent," the official said.

Some overseas lenders have already moved to proactively identify at-risk borrowers and offer financial counseling before problems escalate. NatWest, a British bank, uses an early-warning detection framework built on its own data and credit information to identify borrowers who may face financial difficulties in the future. On that basis, the bank reaches out to those borrowers first, provides financial counseling and introduces appropriate support options.


hyuk@heraldcorp.com