Artist, the talent agency of which actor Lee Jung-jae is the largest shareholder, has denied reports that it signed an unfair contract giving Lee an outsized share of revenues, and warned it will take legal action against the outlet that published the story.
In a statement released Wednesday, Artist said it had provided detailed explanations to Dispatch — the outlet that ran the report — covering the structure of its actor settlement contracts, the circumstances of its registered office relocation, the basis for calculating rent, the economic substance of its contract with Bena Beauty, and the background to various investment and business restructuring decisions. "However, the article selectively cited some of our explanations in a perfunctory manner and was written in a way that concentrated a negative impression on Lee Jung-jae personally," the agency said. It added that it would "carefully review whether important contrary facts were omitted, whether facts were distorted, and whether defamation occurred," and that it planned to pursue legal remedies including demands for correction and rebuttal coverage as well as damages claims.
Earlier that day, Dispatch reported that Artist — in which Lee holds the largest stake and fellow actor Jung Woo-sung holds the second largest — had entered into a preferential contract with Lee.
Under the arrangement as described by Dispatch, Lee and Artist split revenues from Lee's activities 9 to 1, with any earnings above 4 billion won ($2.99 million) going entirely to Lee at a ratio of 10 to 0. As a result, even though Lee reportedly earned more than 20 billion won from "Squid Game" seasons 2 and 3, the company was entitled to only 400 million won — 10 percent of the 4 billion won threshold. Dispatch characterized the terms as exceptional compared with contracts for other artists on the agency's roster. Artist posted an operating loss of 4 billion won last year and has recorded a 2.4 billion won operating loss through the third quarter of this year. Its share price has fallen more than 70 percent over the past two years.
Artist pushed back on the characterization, saying the report made it appear as though Lee had "used his position as a major shareholder to grant himself special benefits." The agency said a fellow actor who served alongside Lee as an inside director also received no separate executive salary, and that "the same settlement contract terms applied equally to both actors." The colleague referred to is Jung Woo-sung.
On the question of why the company received relatively little revenue from "Squid Game," Artist said it was because it did not perform the relevant work directly. "Contracting and overseas agency work related to 'Squid Game' was handled by CAA in the United States, and the associated fees were paid to CAA," the agency said. "Although we did not directly carry out the contracting or overseas work for that production, we received a share of the revenue under the existing settlement contract." It added that the appropriateness of the revenue-sharing cap "must be assessed by taking into account not only the additional amount the company could have received, but also who actually performed the work, who bore the costs, and the revenue the company already received."
Dispatch also reported that after Raemong Raein was acquired by Artist, the company unnecessarily relocated its office to a building owned by Lee that had been sitting vacant, thereby generating rental income for Lee.
Artist said the move was unavoidable. "In the course of legal disputes — including a damages lawsuit filed against the former major shareholder of Raemong Raein — we were compelled to secure a separate office in order to continue management activities and carry out our work," the agency said.
Artist also denied a report that Lee personally profited through a contract between his private company, Bena Beauty, and Artist that included a minimum guarantee arrangement.
The agency said that given Lee's standard advertising modeling fees running into the hundreds of millions of won, the annual minimum guarantee of 30 million won was "a very limited amount." It added that Lee's side had initially considered forgoing the minimum guarantee entirely for the benefit of the company, but settled on the minimal figure after accounting for tax issues that would arise from providing rights free of charge.
Artist further explained that under the contract, Bena Beauty receives only a portion of profits exceeding a mutually agreed target operating profit, and receives no performance-linked income beyond the minimum guarantee until that target is reached. Any excess profit not distributed to Bena Beauty is required to be reinvested in the business, the agency said.
paq@heraldcorp.com
