Appeals court backs cancellation, as lower court did
Court: safety and risk review was not thorough enough
Ruling cites impact on ecosystem stability
An appeals court has ruled for the second time that the master plan for Saemangeum International Airport must be canceled, finding that the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport failed to give adequate weight to public interests in safety and environmental protection.
The Seoul High Court's Administrative Division 4-2, presided over by Judges Lee Gwang-man, Moon Gwang-seop and Park Yeon-wook, ruled Wednesday in favor of the plaintiffs — the Joint Action to Scrap Saemangeum New Airport — in their appeal against the ministry, upholding the lower court's decision to cancel the airport development master plan.
The court acknowledged that three residents living within the legally designated noise-support zone had standing to bring the suit, and went on to say the development plan must be canceled.
"Even giving full consideration to the public interest the ministry sought to achieve through the construction of Saemangeum International Airport, it appears to have assigned disproportionate weight to development benefits without adequately reviewing and assessing the public interests of safety of life and body and environmental protection," the court said.
The court then said that while the site-selection model for the new airport showed significantly higher risk levels than those of other domestic airports, the ministry had concluded that the likelihood of bird strikes was low — relying primarily on the operational experience of the nearby Gunsan Airport — without closely examining the site's locational characteristics and associated risks.
The court added that "the public interest in development is premised on the ability to operate the airport safely," and that "aviation safety must be given particularly important consideration in selecting an airport site, as a single bird-strike accident can cause serious harm to the lives, bodies and property of many people."
The court also noted that the project could reduce bird habitats, warning that "the loss of biodiversity resulting from a decline in bird populations and the degradation of habitat will affect the structural stability of the ecosystem."
Saemangeum International Airport is a project to build a runway, passenger terminal, cargo terminal and other facilities on a 3.4 million-square-meter site in the Saemangeum area of North Jeolla Province, with a target completion date of 2028. The Joint Action filed suit in September 2022 seeking cancellation of the plan.
The lower court had also ruled in favor of the Joint Action in September last year.
At the time, the court found that the ministry had not conducted a comparative review of bird-strike risks when selecting the site during the feasibility planning stage, and had "deliberately understated the level of risk." It added that the plan must be canceled because the ministry had "exceeded its discretion by failing to ensure the legitimacy and objectivity of its balancing of interests."
notstrong@heraldcorp.com
