An appeals court has overturned a life sentence handed to a man in his 60s who stabbed a restaurant owner couple — killing the wife — because he did not receive a free lottery ticket, reducing the punishment to a fixed prison term after citing the defendant's payment of medical expenses to the surviving victim.
Seoul High Court's 13th Criminal Division overturned the life sentence imposed at trial and resentenced Kim, 60, to 45 years in prison on Oct. 29, according to legal sources. Kim had been indicted on charges of murder and attempted murder. The court upheld a separate order requiring Kim to wear an electronic tracking device for 15 years.
Kim was brought to trial on charges of attacking a restaurant owner couple with a bladed weapon at an eatery in Suyu-dong, Gangbuk-gu, Seoul, in late October last year.
The restaurant owner, a woman in her 60s, was rushed to the hospital with serious injuries but died. Her husband, who was also attacked, sustained injuries requiring six weeks of recovery and later suffered aftereffects including hearing loss.
Investigators found that Kim had harbored a grievance over not receiving a 1,000-won lottery ticket the restaurant offered as a complimentary gift to customers who paid in cash.
After receiving a life sentence at trial, Kim appealed on grounds of diminished mental capacity, citing a past history of schizophrenia and the detection of drugs in his urine following the attack.
The appeals court acknowledged that Kim's actions were deserving of condemnation, but determined that the life sentence was somewhat excessive when weighed against various sentencing factors.
The court particularly took into account that Kim had paid the surviving victim — the restaurant owner's husband — 5.32 million won ($4,000) in medical expenses after the attack.
The court noted that the amount alone could not be considered sufficient compensation for the physical and mental suffering the victim had endured, but said Kim's efforts toward restitution could be reflected in sentencing to some degree.
Kim's mental state at the time of the attack also influenced the appeals court's decision. Kim had a history of treatment and hospitalization for schizophrenia and was found to have been drinking while on medication when the attack occurred.
The court found that these circumstances did not meet the legal threshold for a sentence reduction based on diminished mental capacity, but acknowledged the possibility that Kim's mental state had not been fully intact at the time.
The court also took into consideration that Kim was 60 years old and would be required to wear an electronic monitoring device for 15 years.
During the investigation, Kim reportedly stated having no memory of the incident. Kim also told investigators that he had habitually carried three bladed weapons out of fear that others might harm him.
123@heraldcorp.com
