Ryu Ok-hada, who quit over medical school expansion, sued two commenters
Online remarks included 'it's about money' and 'axis of evil'
Ryu lost the damages suit
A court has ruled that online comments targeting a resident doctor who resigned in protest over the government's medical school enrollment expansion — including remarks such as "it's ultimately about money" and "you are the axis of evil" — do not constitute defamation.
According to legal sources, Judge Jeong Woo-seok of the Seoul Central District Court's Civil Division 85 ruled against the plaintiff on Nov. 3 in a damages suit filed by Ryu Ok-hada, former representative of interns at Catholic Central Medical Center, against two commenters identified as A and B. Ryu had argued that A and B defamed Ryu and demanded 1 million won ($751) in damages from each, but the court rejected the claim.
In February 2024, Ryu told a media outlet that the government's push to expand medical school enrollment amounted to "healthcare dictatorship," adding that Ryu had submitted a resignation "out of a sense of duty, despite feeling scared and afraid." Commenter A responded to the article by writing "ultimately, it's about money," while commenter B wrote, "Doctors, stop talking nonsense," "you rotten people," and "you are the axis of evil."
Ryu filed the damages suit in December 2024, arguing that the comments defamed and insulted Ryu and demanding 1 million won in emotional distress damages from each commenter.
The court rejected Ryu's claims.
Citing Supreme Court precedent, the court noted that "expressing critical opinions about others cannot be considered unlawful except in extremely exceptional circumstances" and that liability arises "only in exceptional cases, such as when the expression amounts to contemptuous personal attacks."
The court added that "taking into account all circumstances — including the content and overall context of the article, the background and substance of the comments, the manner of expression, and the social atmosphere at the time — it is difficult to conclude that the comments constituted unlawful conduct."
The court further explained that "even if some of the comments contained somewhat insulting or contemptuous expressions, their primary intent was to emphasize critical views of doctors or to characterize their actions negatively, with some degree of exaggeration in the process."
It concluded that "since it is difficult to find that the comments stated specific facts to damage Ryu's reputation or used excessively insulting language to violate Ryu's personal rights, all of Ryu's claims are without merit."
The ruling has not yet been finalized. The deadline for Ryu to appeal the first-instance decision has not passed.
Meanwhile, the government convened the Health and Medical Policy Deliberation Committee in February and finalized a plan to increase the total medical school enrollment quota by 3,342 over five years beginning next year.
notstrong@heraldcorp.com
