929 target cuts vs. 178 raises — a 5.2-to-1 ratio
NHN leads with 13 upgrades; Cosmax and Pumtek Korea each get 9
NHN surges 50.52% even as Kospi drops 14.66%
A sharp selloff in South Korean equities this month has pushed brokerage target-price cuts to more than five times the number of upgrades — yet NHN, Cosmax and Pumtek Korea have bucked the trend, drawing a wave of upward revisions and posting double-digit share-price gains even in a falling market.
According to FnGuide, a financial data provider, brokerages issued 929 target-price downgrade research notes from Nov. 1 through Wednesday, compared with just 178 upgrades — a ratio of 5.2 to one. The pace of cuts is striking: in all of October, brokerages issued 929 downgrades and 281 upgrades, meaning the November downgrade count matched an entire month's worth in roughly two weeks.
Even as the broader analyst community lowered its sights, a handful of companies drew repeated target-price increases on the back of earnings growth and expectations for further business expansion. Among the 178 upgrade notes, NHN topped the list with 13, followed by Cosmax and Pumtek Korea with nine each.
The share-price divergence from the broader market has been equally striking. From the Oct. 30 closing price through Wednesday, Kospi and Kosdaq fell 14.66 percent and 12.00 percent, respectively. NHN surged 50.52 percent over the same period, while Cosmax and Pumtek Korea rose 19.35 percent and 18.43 percent.
Analysts attributed NHN's leading upgrade count to improving earnings across its existing businesses and rapid expansion into AI data centers. The company's third-quarter consolidated operating profit came in at 58.8 billion won ($44.2 million), up 112.8 percent from a year earlier. Analysts also viewed positively NHN's plan to install about 1,700 Nvidia B300 GPUs at data centers it has secured in Gasan, Seoul, and Gajwa, Incheon, with sequential operation set to begin in January next year.
Sun Yu-jin, a researcher at LS Securities, raised the target price for NHN from 74,000 won to 97,000 won. "What had initially been a concern — a potential cloud growth plateau in 2027 — has been resolved through early lease agreements for AI data centers, enabling swift demand response and easing valuation pressure," Sun said. "With a stable earnings base from the gaming and payments businesses, the full-year contribution from the GPU business and the early rollout of B300 infrastructure in the greater Seoul area are expected to drive a notable improvement in profitability in 2027."
Cosmax continued to attract target-price upgrades on the strength of expanding K-beauty exports and production capacity scale-ups. The company's third-quarter consolidated operating profit reached 83.3 billion won, up 94.9 percent year-on-year and above market expectations. Sales of basic skincare products by its domestic unit rose, while its US subsidiary posted 88 percent revenue growth driven by increased orders from local indie brands. Once an expansion of its Pyeongtaek factory is completed at year-end, annual production capacity is expected to reach 1.1 billion units.
Song Ji-yeon, a researcher at Sangsangin Investment & Securities, raised the target price for Cosmax from 400,000 won to 430,000 won. "Amid the K-beauty boom, all domestic and overseas subsidiaries are showing balanced growth, and we note that the company's supply footprint within its global customer base continues to expand," Song said.
Pumtek Korea also earned positive assessments as rising demand for cosmetics packaging — driven by the growth of K-beauty indie brands — lifted its results. Third-quarter consolidated operating profit rose 64 percent year-on-year to 25.1 billion won, a record high on a quarterly basis. As orders from small and mid-sized cosmetics brands increase, expectations are also growing that large packaging manufacturers with sufficient production capacity will capture additional orders.
Lee Seung-eun, a researcher at Yuanta Securities Korea, raised the target price for Pumtek Korea from 80,000 won to 108,000 won. "Orders could shift toward large packaging manufacturers with available production capacity, creating an opportunity for additional contracts and a potential catalyst for share-price gains," Lee said.
Analysts say investors should prepare for a stock-picker's market in which returns diverge based on individual company earnings, as capital that had been concentrated in large-cap semiconductor shares rotates into other names.
In a research note released Wednesday, Lee Gyeong-su of Hana Securities examined the six periods when investor attention was most heavily concentrated in semiconductor stocks: September 2017, January and November 2020, December 2021, September 2023, and June 2024. The analysis found that the dispersion in individual stock returns widened more significantly in the four-to-twelve months after semiconductor-stock concentration peaked than in the first three months.
During those windows, the top 20 percent of stocks by analyst earnings-estimate upgrades outperformed the bottom 20 percent by an average of 13.6 percentage points. The top 20 percent by target-price increases beat the bottom 20 percent by an average of 11.0 percentage points. In both cases, the top-ranked stocks outperformed across all six historical episodes. "Looking at past periods of semiconductor-stock concentration, the stock-picker's market tended to emerge after the initial three months rather than during them," Lee said.
hajun825@heraldcorp.com
