Instructor Noh Hyeong-seok speaks of emotional toll amid cheating allegations
Lee Jin-woo, 32, the LEET perfect scorer at the center of an unprecedented AI-cheating scandal on the College Scholastic Ability Test, failed to appear Thursday at the public verification event he had pledged to attend, while an active instructor who had publicly raised the cheating allegations broke down in tears.
IDA Admissions Research Institute, which organized the on-site verification, held a roundtable with working instructors at a venue in Daechi-dong, Gangnam-gu, Seoul, discussing the Lee case and the cheating allegations. Instead of streaming Lee solving the CSAT Korean-language section live on YouTube as planned, the institute conducted a panel discussion with instructors and a question-and-answer session with reporters.
Noh Hyeong-seok, a LEET instructor at Mega Law School who himself once scored a perfect mark on the LEET verbal reasoning section, opened by saying, "This week has honestly been so hard. The growing public attention has weighed on me."
Noh analyzed Lee's answer sheet on a YouTube channel Saturday, raising questions about the process by which certain answers were changed.
"When I first saw him, I was envious — he had achieved something remarkable in the field I work in," Noh said. "At first I wasn't particularly interested, but I happened to come across his answer sheet, and the final answers he marked didn't connect with the reasoning process he must have gone through to get there. That's the point I questioned."
"I later looked up videos of him, and the account he gave in interviews of how he prepared for the exam didn't square with the results he achieved," Noh said. "The process felt far too effortless."
"When asked specifically how he studied, he said something like, 'The essence is similar, so if you stick to the essence, the results will follow,'" Noh said. "But the essence is actually studying hard enough, in the right direction. If you can say you didn't do well because you couldn't eat properly or the lights were too bright at night, doesn't that make studying sound easy?"
"Thinking about that, I felt like my work was being mocked," Noh said, his voice breaking. "If he's a great genius, then a genius was mocking what I do. If it was a lie, then a liar was mocking my work. That's what hurt." He then wiped away tears.
Noh said that when IDA Admissions Research Institute first contacted him about the verification, he did not trust the organization either. "I didn't know who they were, so I said I would bring my own clothes, stationery and answer sheets," he said, dabbing at his tears. "I even bought a pair of Lululemon pants for 40,000 won ($30) — something I would never normally spend on underwear."
Earlier, on Saturday, Noh had analyzed Lee's answer sheet on the YouTube channel "Heugwoo Story," noting that Lee had initially chosen clearly wrong answers on science and economics passages — questions a test-taker at a perfect-score level would easily identify. "There is no way to connect the reasoning behind those initial choices," Noh said at the time, adding that the selections were "too anomalous to be explained by a lapse in concentration in the latter half." He proposed sitting down with Lee, past exam questions in hand, to hear the thought process directly.
In response, Lee announced he would stream himself solving the CSAT Korean-language section live on YouTube on exam day, with reporters and observers present on-site, to dispel the cheating allegations.
IDA Admissions Research Institute said Lee had not arrived by 8:37 a.m. and declared the public verification closed. "Even if Lee were to show up now, there would be a risk of the exam questions being leaked, so it could not be considered a fair verification — it would only add to the suspicions," the institute said. "We will not recognize any public verification at this point."
jshan@heraldcorp.com
