South Korea's four major duty-free operators all posted operating profits in the third quarter, buoyed by a rise in foreign tourist arrivals. However, companies that aggressively expanded their footprint saw profits fall and margins remain thin, revealing a split in profitability across the sector.
The combined operating profit of Lotte, Hotel Shilla, Shinsegae and Hyundai duty-free shops came to 70.9 billion won ($53 million) in the third quarter, according to the duty-free industry Thursday. That marked a 34.2 percent decline from the second quarter's 107.8 billion won, with all four operators recording lower profits than the previous quarter.
Lotte Duty Free led in sales with 926.4 billion won, up 28.0 percent from a year earlier — a gain attributed to its launch of operations at Incheon International Airport's DF1 zone in April. Operating profit, however, fell 17.5 percent year-on-year to 15.1 billion won, down from 18.3 billion won in the same period last year, and was roughly half the 31.9 billion won recorded in the second quarter. Its operating profit margin for the quarter was 1.6 percent.
Hyundai Duty Free, which took over the airport's DF2 zone around the same time, posted sales of 366.6 billion won, up 64.8 percent year-on-year, and operating profit of 3.2 billion won, a 145.6 percent increase. Even so, profit fell from 6.2 billion won in the prior quarter, and its operating profit margin remained at just 0.9 percent.
Hotel Shilla and Shinsegae, by contrast, saw sales decline but improved their profitability compared with a year earlier. Both operators had previously surrendered some of their Incheon Airport concessions, citing the high cost of rent.
Hotel Shilla's duty-free and travel retail segment posted sales of 760.3 billion won, down 10.5 percent year-on-year, but swung to an operating profit of 27.3 billion won from a loss of 10.4 billion won in the same period last year. Profit still slipped 25.0 percent from 36.4 billion won in the second quarter, and the operating profit margin eased 1.1 percentage points to 3.6 percent from 4.7 percent in the prior quarter.
Shinsegae Duty Free also turned profitable, posting operating profit of 25.3 billion won despite a 16.3 percent drop in sales to 451.1 billion won, helped in part by savings on airport rent. Its operating profit margin of 5.6 percent was the highest among the four operators in the third quarter.
A deeper concern for the industry is that foreign tourist spending has not kept pace with the growth in visitor numbers. According to the Korea Duty Free Association, the number of foreign shoppers reached about 1.27 million in September, up 25 percent from a year earlier.
Yet foreign tourist sales that month fell 3.8 percent year-on-year to 751.4 billion won. Spending per visitor dropped roughly 23 percent, from about 770,000 won to 593,000 won. The divergence has prompted concern in some corners of the industry that competition to attract Chinese daigou resellers could heat up again as operators seek to defend their revenue.
korean@heraldcorp.com
