Supreme Court's Second Division rejects prosecution appeal, upholding not-guilty verdicts from lower courts
Insurers face separate administrative suits over Fair Trade Commission fines
Three non-life insurers charged with colluding in insurance contract bids issued by the Korea Land and Housing Corporation have been acquitted by the Supreme Court.
The Supreme Court's Second Division, presided over by Justice Kwon Young-jun, rejected the prosecution's appeal Thursday and upheld the not-guilty verdicts against Samsung Fire, Hanwha General Insurance and Meritz Fire, which had been indicted on charges of violating the Fair Trade Act.
Prosecutors alleged that Samsung Fire and Hanwha General Insurance conspired around December 2017 to rig a bid for LH's comprehensive property insurance on rental housing, ensuring that one insurer — identified only as Company A — would win the contract. Prosecutors further alleged that Meritz Fire joined the scheme in February 2018, with all three insurers helping Company A secure a jeonse rental housing fire insurance contract in exchange for a share of the premiums.
Prosecutors argued the companies exploited a standard industry practice in which a winning insurer takes out reinsurance, and the reinsurer in turn takes out retrocession coverage to spread risk, using that structure to facilitate the alleged collusion.
The trial court acquitted all three, finding that chat logs and text messages submitted as evidence by insurer employees were insufficient to establish a conspiracy.
Prosecutors appealed, but the second court also returned not-guilty verdicts. The Supreme Court, nine months later, found no error in those rulings and confirmed the acquittals.
Although the insurers have escaped criminal liability, a separate dispute over Korea Fair Trade Commission fines remains unresolved. The commission imposed corrective orders and fines in April 2022, citing unfair concerted practices in connection with the bids. The insurers filed administrative suits seeking to have the penalties overturned. According to each company's third-quarter report, Hanwha General Insurance is contesting a fine of 263 million won ($197,000) in a first-instance administrative trial, with the next hearing scheduled for Jan. 20. A second-instance ruling in Samsung Fire's suit — involving a claim amount of about 126 million won — is set for Nov. 26.
won@heraldcorp.com
