Doctor sentenced to 1 year in prison, suspended, for drunk driving without a license

License revoked under amended Medical Act; administrative lawsuit dismissed

Seoul Administrative Court rules law does not violate freedom of occupation

This image is for illustrative purposes only and is not directly related to the article. [Getty Images Bank]
This image is for illustrative purposes only and is not directly related to the article. [Getty Images Bank]

A court has ruled for the first time that an amended medical law requiring the mandatory revocation of a doctor's license upon conviction of any crime carrying a sentence of imprisonment or heavier is constitutional. The ruling marks the first time a court has upheld the amended Medical Act as constitutional in an administrative lawsuit arising from its actual application.

The 12th Administrative Division of the Seoul Administrative Court said Monday that it had ruled against a doctor, identified only as A, who had sued the Minister of Health and Welfare seeking to overturn the revocation of the doctor's medical license. The court issued its ruling on Thursday.

"The relevant provision of the Medical Act is intended to protect the public interest by securing trust in medical professionals," the court said. "It reflects the public's legal sentiment that people want to be treated by doctors who have never been punished with imprisonment or heavier for any crime."

The court added that this represents "the general interest of community members who have no choice but to entrust their lives, physical integrity and health to medical professionals," and said the license revocation does not violate the principle of proportionality, given that it is temporary in nature.

A was convicted in May 2024 at trial of driving without a license while intoxicated, with a blood alcohol concentration of 0.121 percent — above the threshold for license revocation — and was sentenced to one year in prison, suspended for two years. After the sentence was upheld on appeal and confirmed by the Supreme Court, the Ministry of Health and Welfare revoked A's medical license in July under the amended Medical Act.

The amended Medical Act, revised in May 2023, requires the revocation of a medical professional's license upon conviction of any crime carrying a sentence of imprisonment or heavier, including suspended sentences. Previously, a license could be revoked only when a medical professional was convicted of violating medical-related laws. The old standard drew criticism for allowing doctors who committed crimes such as sex offenses or drunk driving to keep their licenses.

After the license was revoked, A filed suit arguing that mandatory revocation solely on the grounds of receiving a sentence of imprisonment or heavier for a general crime unrelated to medical practice violated the freedom of occupation. The court dismissed the claim.

The court also rejected on Thursday A's request to refer the amended Medical Act provision to the Constitutional Court for a constitutionality review.

"When a suspended sentence of imprisonment or heavier is handed down for a general crime, the degree of social culpability is by no means small, and therefore the revocation cannot be seen as an excessive infringement on the freedom of occupation," the court said.

"At a time when cases involving similar legal issues are being filed in succession, this ruling carries significant weight," a court official said.


notstrong@heraldcorp.com