Moody's defies market expectations, keeps 'Aa3' rating
Rating stands one notch above Fitch, S&P assessments
Fiscal deficit at 5.4% of GDP as nationwide protests spread
Moody's defied market expectations Friday (local time), keeping France's sovereign credit rating at Aa3 with a negative outlook — a decision that surprised analysts who had anticipated a downgrade amid the country's deepening fiscal instability.
Last year, Fitch and S&P cut France's sovereign rating to A+, the equivalent of Moody's A1, prompting markets to expect Moody's would follow suit and lower France's rating one notch from Aa3 to A1.
France is struggling to restore fiscal health as its budget deficit stands at 5.4 percent of GDP, compounded by a fragmented parliament with no majority party in the lower house, slowing economic growth and rising interest rates. Nationwide protests over inadequate public investment and high prices have further stiffened public opposition to austerity measures.
According to Bloomberg and Reuters, Moody's said in a statement that the process of passing the 2027 budget "is taking place at a time of the most widespread protests in recent years," but added that its baseline assumption was that "a budget reducing the fiscal deficit will ultimately be adopted" despite the difficult political and social conditions.
The decision gave the government of President Emmanuel Macron, which has been under mounting pressure from fiscal turmoil and spreading protests, relief from a further rating cut. Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu said after the Moody's decision that it "recognizes the solidity of our economy and the credibility of the budget presented by the government."
France's challenges remain, however. Lecornu had put forward a budget aimed at boosting tax revenue and sharply curbing spending to improve the country's finances, but its passage is uncertain given the divided parliament. The government can invoke a constitutional provision to push through a budget without a parliamentary vote in urgent circumstances, but doing so would risk a no-confidence motion.
On Friday, the lower house rejected the revenue portion of the government's social security budget, sending the original bill to the Senate. The lower house is set to begin debating the main budget bill next week.
French government bond yields remain elevated. The yield on France's 10-year government bond climbed to 5.14 percent on Thursday — its highest level since 2002 — while the spread over Germany's 10-year bond yield, considered a safe-haven asset, widened to 1.78 percentage points.
Mike Bell, global market strategist at RBC BlueBay Asset Management, told Reuters that if all three major credit rating agencies were to downgrade France further after the presidential election, "things could get a lot worse from there."
eyre@heraldcorp.com
