Photo is not directly related to the article's specific content. [Getty Images Bank]
Photo is not directly related to the article's specific content. [Getty Images Bank]

American billionaires are buying ultra-luxury mansions for as much as 205 billion won ($155 million) and demolishing them within months. As cases multiply of even relatively new high-end homes being razed to make way for custom builds, so-called "trophy-home teardowns" have emerged as a new phenomenon in the US real estate market.

What these buyers are paying hundreds of billions of won for is not the mansion itself but the land beneath it. They are demolishing perfectly intact structures to secure rare, high-value sites — beachfront lots, hilltops and other locations where supply is essentially fixed. Some real estate brokerages have begun using AI to render images of properties with the existing structures removed, marketing the bare land as the selling point.

The trend is concentrated around Palm Beach, Florida, where the number of billionaires buying and then demolishing luxury estates has been growing, the Wall Street Journal reported Wednesday (local time). The phenomenon is spreading to other wealthy enclaves across the United States where developable land is scarce.

A prominent example is William Lauder, a billionaire heir to the Estée Lauder cosmetics dynasty.

In March 2023, he purchased a Palm Beach oceanfront estate for $155 million — a record price for the area at the time. The property had belonged to the late Rush Limbaugh, the conservative radio host.

Built in the early 1990s, the main residence spanned about 2,230 square meters and featured a grand reception hall modeled on the Palace of Versailles and a study replicating the library of the Biltmore Estate in North Carolina. Elaborately carved angel figures adorned the ceilings.

Lauder demolished the structure just four months after buying it, in July 2023.

The mansion was roughly 30 years old at the time, but what drew Lauder was neither its history nor its lavish interiors — it was the expansive oceanfront lot and the scarcity of comparable locations along the Atlantic.

It was not the first time Lauder had torn down a trophy home.

He had previously demolished two houses on another Palm Beach oceanfront site — one of them only six years old.

He had originally planned to build his own residence there, but changed course after acquiring the Limbaugh property. The roughly three-acre beachfront lot he cleared by demolishing those structures sold last year for about $200 million, demonstrating that stripped land itself can command an astronomical price.

The pattern of land value outstripping the worth of the structures on it has become increasingly pronounced in the US luxury housing market. Real estate appraiser Jonathan Miller told the Wall Street Journal that as land prices rise, the cost of constructing a new building accounts for a shrinking share of a property's total value. Beachfront enclaves are particularly constrained: no amount of money can create new oceanfront land, so buyers are opting to purchase existing homes outright and demolish them to claim the site.

The teardown wave shows no sign of slowing.

The Wall Street Journal reported Friday that real estate developers Todd Michael Glaser and David Edelstein had signed a contract to purchase a Palm Beach oceanfront estate for about $160 million.

The property — roughly two acres — was owned by the late developer Murray Goodman and his wife. The pink structure, built in the 1980s, has 12 bedrooms across a main house and a guesthouse.

It was listed last November for about $185 million and is in good condition.

The developers plan to demolish the existing mansion and subdivide the lot to build two new homes, though the deal has not yet closed, as it is contingent on splitting the site into two separate tax parcels.

Similar cases are emerging in nearby Manalapan.

David MacNeil, founder of automotive accessories company WeatherTech, last year purchased an unfinished mega-mansion adjacent to land he already owned for $55.5 million. He demolished the structure and merged the lots to assemble a roughly 3.5-acre oceanfront site, which sold in April for $105 million.

MacNeil also purchased a roughly 836-square-meter home next to his residence in July for $36 million and tore it down. The house, built around 2004, will be replaced by a fitness facility and green space. MacNeil said the property looked fine from the outside but its systems were outdated, and bringing it up to modern standards would have cost roughly $10 million.

The luxury real estate brokerage industry is adapting to match. Some agents now emphasize what a buyer could do with the land after demolition rather than highlighting a home's interiors or architectural features. They use AI to generate images showing the lot cleared of its existing structure, or to visualize a new custom mansion in its place.

Oracle founder Larry Ellison has relisted a North Palm Beach estate built in the 1990s for about $165 million. Although the existing structure is in good condition, there is speculation that a new buyer could demolish and rebuild it. Broker Dina Goldentayer said ultra-high-net-worth buyers are often dissatisfied with the design of homes less than a decade old, and that demand is growing among buyers who want to secure a coveted location and then configure every interior space — kitchens, bathrooms and beyond — entirely to their own taste.

The teardown trend is spreading beyond Florida. According to real estate platform Redfin, more than 15 percent of listings in Bunker Hill Village, an affluent Houston, Texas, neighborhood, contained language referencing reconstruction or land value. In Pimmit Hills, Virginia, such language appeared in 6.67 percent of listings.

The phenomenon is not limited to billionaires. Near Destin, Florida, a pair of retired retail executives bought a beachfront property in 2020 for about $3.7 million, demolished the existing home and spent five years building a new one. The completed house was listed for about $18.9 million — a case study in acquiring a scarce coastal lot through the purchase and demolition of whatever happened to sit on it.

Environmental concerns are mounting, however. Sustainability consultancy WAP Sustainability estimates that demolishing a roughly 929-square-meter home and constructing a new one of about 2,787 square meters generates a carbon footprint equivalent to the annual electricity consumption of 250 average American households. Large-scale construction requires substantial quantities of concrete and steel; demolition generates waste, and producing and transporting materials for the new structure adds further emissions.

The construction industry argues that much of the material from demolition sites can be recycled. Robert Burridge, a luxury homebuilder in Florida, said only about 25 percent of demolition waste ends up in landfills, with appliances, furniture, concrete and metal either donated or recycled.

Across the US luxury real estate market, a property's location and development potential are increasingly driving transaction prices more than the size or condition of the structure on it. Coastal and other scarce sites command high prices regardless of what stands on them. The spectacle of billionaires spending hundreds of billions of won on mansions only to tear them down illustrates just how dominant land value has become in the real estate calculus of America's ultra-wealthy.


rainbow@heraldcorp.com