Conservatives who backed Trump's reelection worry about alienating Catholic base; feud with popular American-born pope seen as political liability ahead of midterms
Republicans are growing alarmed after Donald Trump turned his fire on the pope, with the party worried that publicly attacking the spiritual leader of 1.4 billion Catholics worldwide carries serious political costs — and could drive away the conservative Catholic voters who were central to Trump's reelection.
At the White House on April 13, Trump told reporters he had "nothing to apologize for" over his attacks on Pope Leo XIV. "He was wrong," Trump said. The day before, Trump had posted on his Truth Social platform suggesting that Leo XIV would never have become pope without him, and telling the pontiff to stay out of politics and focus on his religious duties.
Trump also posted an image depicting himself as Jesus healing the sick. After the image drew widespread condemnation as blasphemous, he deleted it — but refused to apologize for his remarks about the pope.
Republicans have been visibly unsettled by Trump's decision to go after the pope. Attacking the head of the world's Catholic Church carries significant political risk.
The most immediate concern is losing the support of conservative Catholic voters who helped deliver Trump's reelection. According to The Washington Post, Catholic voters backed Trump over Democratic candidate Kamala Harris by a margin of 20 percentage points in the 2024 presidential election. The New York Times noted that white Catholics in particular voted for Trump by wide margins in all three presidential elections in which he ran.
Leo XIV's standing as the first American-born pope has made him especially popular domestically. The war with Iran, by contrast, has drawn low public support at home. Trump's decision to pick a fight with a widely admired pope who has called for an end to that war risks deepening voter resentment.
Bishop Robert Barron, a member of the religious freedom commission Trump himself established, said April 13 that Trump's Truth Social posts about the pope were "entirely inappropriate and disrespectful" and called on him to apologize. Trump's refusal is expected to intensify the backlash from conservative Catholic circles.
The war with Iran has already pushed oil prices higher, adding to the Republican Party's headaches ahead of the midterm elections. Now, with Trump also feuding publicly with the pope over the conflict, some within the party fear their support base could erode rapidly.
Some have urged Vice President JD Vance — a Catholic convert — to play a mediating role. But in a Fox News interview the day before, Vance sided with Trump, saying the pope should stay out of American politics and confine himself to matters of morality.
kate01@heraldcorp.com
