The defense for Kim Hyun-tae, the former commander of the Army Special Warfare Command's 707th Special Mission Battalion, denied all charges Tuesday at the start of his appeal trial — repeating the position he took at the first trial, where he was sentenced to prison for his role in blockading the National Assembly during the Dec. 3 emergency martial law.
According to Yonhap, Kim's attorney told Seoul High Court's Criminal Division 12-2 — presided over by Judges Jo Jin-gu, Kim Min-a and Lee Seung-cheol — at the first hearing of the appeal on charges including participation in key duties of insurrection that "unlike the first-instance ruling, both the intent to undermine the constitutional order and the intent to riot and commit insurrection must be denied," and argued for acquittal.
The attorney said the mission Kim received from former Special Warfare Command chief Kwak Jong-geun during the emergency martial law was to "secure" the exterior of the National Assembly building that houses the main chamber.
That amounted to simply locking the building's doors, the attorney said, adding that the order to enter the building and remove people inside was given not to the 707th Special Mission Battalion but to the 1st Airborne Special Forces Brigade.
"When the defendant arrived at the main entrance, for some reason people who had no business being there — National Assembly staff, journalists and others who were not lawmakers — had already arrived and were obstructing the mission," the attorney said. "Unable to abandon the mission, the defendant decided to go around to the right side and broke a window in a darkened room to enter."
The attorney said the unit then tried to seal only the main entrance and withdraw immediately, but was attacked with fire extinguishers by others at the scene, which unintentionally forced them to move through the third and fourth floors and below-ground floors before they could pull out.
The attorney also said that during this process, former commander Kwak asked whether blank rounds or a Taser could be used, to which Kim replied, "There are too many people. It's dangerous," and refused the order.
"How could this possibly warrant a 12-year prison sentence? It makes no sense," the attorney said. "The rioting was carried out not by the 707th Special Mission Battalion but by the far greater number of civilians who got there first."
The attorney also said the first-instance court found that 19 members of the 707th Special Mission Battalion broke two windows and infiltrated the building in just two minutes. "Common sense says it would take at least five minutes," the attorney said.
The attorney doubled down on a request for an on-site inspection, saying "the only way to challenge the special prosecutor's indictment, which was written on imagination, is for the court to go there in person and see the height of the wall and the thickness of the windows."
Kim was indicted in February last year on charges of participating in key duties of insurrection for his involvement in blockading and infiltrating the National Assembly during the emergency martial law.
In August this year, the first-instance court found that Kim had entered the National Assembly on orders from former commander Kwak, blockaded the chamber and attempted to stop lawmakers from voting on a motion to lift martial law, and sentenced him to 12 years in prison, ordering his detention in the courtroom.
Kim subsequently filed for bail and then for the cancellation of his detention during the appeal proceedings, but both requests were denied.
husn7@heraldcorp.com
