Second-half audit criteria identical to first half
AI security checks left to individual firms' discretion
Experts call for verified penetration testing and vulnerability follow-up
Even as AI-based cyberattacks on the financial sector grow more sophisticated, the Korea Financial Security Institute has kept its website security audit standards for financial firms unchanged. Experts say the inspection framework needs to be strengthened to verify actual attack feasibility, as AI-assisted hacking and complex multi-vulnerability intrusion attacks become increasingly advanced.
Financial firms currently undergoing the institute's second-half website vulnerability assessments — which run from late last month through the end of this month — are being evaluated under the same criteria and methods used in the first half of the year, according to industry sources. A security official at one financial firm said the ongoing second-half audit uses "the same evaluation method and inspection criteria as the first-half audit." The institute has continued carrying out its regular security inspection work for financial firms even after suffering its own hacking incident on Nov. 9.
Under current electronic financial supervision regulations, financial firms are required to conduct vulnerability analyses and assessments of their public-facing websites at least twice a year. They may use the common evaluation criteria developed by the institute and have the work carried out by the institute itself, a private cybersecurity firm, or an in-house dedicated team.
The institute has maintained its existing inspection criteria and methods despite a string of hacking incidents in the financial sector and its own breach. Earlier this year, in February, it announced plans to strengthen audits by expanding the evaluation criteria from 789 items across 14 categories to 869 items across 15 categories, adding new cloud-related items. Those measures, however, were put in place before the recent wave of breaches, and no additional changes to the criteria have been made in response to the incidents.
The central question is whether existing audits are sufficient to keep pace with rapidly evolving hacking techniques. The current evaluation criteria do include items covering user authentication, access control and blocking of automated requests. But as complex multi-vulnerability intrusion attacks grow more sophisticated, verification that reproduces actual attack sequences — rather than checking individual items in isolation — is becoming increasingly important. Another limitation is that audit effectiveness can vary depending on the individual examiner's skill level.
AI-assisted security checks, in particular, are conducted separately by financial firms at their own discretion. A Korea Financial Security Institute official said financial firms "refer to the existing evaluation criteria but may also conduct additional checks using AI or separately commission a cybersecurity firm." Whether and to what extent firms supplement regular audits with verification reflecting the latest attack methods is ultimately left to each firm's judgment.
Experts say the effectiveness of the existing security inspection framework needs to be improved given the recent spate of hacking incidents in the financial sector. Hwang Seok-jin, a professor at Dongguk University's Graduate School of International Information Security, said "questions can be raised about the lack of systemic change even after the Korea Financial Security Institute itself suffered a breach." Hwang added that "it is necessary to incorporate into the inspection framework the changing security environment — including AI-based attacks — and the vulnerabilities exposed in actual incidents."
Hwang also stressed that "it is not enough to simply conduct annual audits — it is important to verify actual penetration feasibility and then confirm whether identified vulnerabilities have been remediated." Hwang called for a shift toward an effectiveness-centered framework that includes penetration testing simulating multi-vulnerability intrusions and the sharing of vulnerabilities discovered at one financial firm with others in the sector.
A Korea Financial Security Institute official said the institute must first determine through its investigation "whether the vulnerability exploited in this incident falls under existing evaluation criteria or represents a new type." The official added that "it is difficult to immediately revise the evaluation criteria when the cause of the incident has not yet been confirmed," and that any improvements based on the investigation's findings "can only be reflected in next year's evaluation criteria," given that the second-half audit is already underway.
snsd@heraldcorp.com
