BOK: rebound in prime areas cannot be ruled out

In 2018, outer-district gains preceded a Gangnam surge

Gangnam down this year while outlying areas rise 3%-plus

Rate hike gains momentum ahead of Nov. 26 policy meeting

Apartment complexes in the Gangnam and Seocho areas as seen from Namsan Park in Jung-gu, Seoul. [Herald DB]
Apartment complexes in the Gangnam and Seocho areas as seen from Namsan Park in Jung-gu, Seoul. [Herald DB]

Apartment prices in Seoul's Gangnam area have been falling for more than two months, yet the Bank of Korea is keeping in mind the possibility that rising prices in outlying districts could once again push up values in prime areas — just as they did in 2017 and 2018.

Data from that period show that while the Gangnam area fell for 14 consecutive weeks, prices in the northeastern and northwestern districts climbed steadily — and Gangnam subsequently rebounded by an even wider margin. Should signs of a similar recovery emerge in Seoul's core neighborhoods, the Bank of Korea's tightening stance would gain further weight.

BOK: if outer-area gains persist, prime districts could follow

According to the Bank of Korea, at last month's 20th Monetary Policy Board meeting, one board member noted that past housing-price cycles typically followed a pattern in which prices first turned weak in prime areas before the broader market corrected. The member added, however, that there had also been cases — as in 2017 and 2018 — where prices in outlying areas kept rising even as prime-area prices adjusted, only for prime-area prices to rebound again.

A Bank of Korea official said that given housing supply conditions and improvements in household income, "the possibility that prime-area housing prices could rise again as they did in the past cannot be ruled out if the upward trend in outlying areas continues." The official added, however, that "uncertainty is high depending on how housing supply progresses and how the tax reform bill is debated in the National Assembly."

An analysis of the Korea Real Estate Board's weekly apartment sale price index for 2017 and 2018 shows that the pattern in question played out between April and October 2018.

After the enforcement of a heavier capital gains tax on multi-home owners in April of that year, apartment prices in the southeastern zone — which includes Gangnam-gu, Seocho-gu, Songpa-gu and Gangdong-gu — fell for 14 consecutive weeks from the second week of April through the second week of July, declining a cumulative 0.65%.

Over the same period, the northwestern zone — covering Mapo-gu, Seodaemun-gu and Eunpyeong-gu — rose 1.75%, while the northeastern zone, which includes Seongbuk-gu, Gangbuk-gu and Nowon-gu, gained 0.96%. Seoul-wide apartment prices rose 0.74% during that stretch. The northeastern zone's momentum strengthened over time: its average weekly gain rose roughly threefold, from 0.04% in the first four weeks of the southeastern zone's decline to 0.12% in the final four weeks.

As surrounding areas rose, the southeastern zone gradually came under upward pressure as well. It turned positive in the third week of July, rising 0.01%, and went on to climb for 14 consecutive weeks through the third week of October, surging 3.4%.

The pattern is widely interpreted as reflecting a shift in demand toward prime areas such as Gangnam as buyers upgraded from outlying districts where prices had already risen. Seoul-wide apartment prices rose 3.1% in that subsequent phase, driven largely by the southeastern zone's gains.

Southeastern zone down 11 straight weeks; northeastern and northwestern zones rise — echoing 2018

A similar divergence has emerged this year, with prices falling in prime areas such as Gangnam in the second half while outlying districts continue to rise.

Southeastern-zone apartment prices fell for 11 consecutive weeks from the last week of August through the second week of November, declining a cumulative 2.1%. Over the same period, the northeastern zone rose 3.25% and the northwestern zone gained 2.74%. Seoul-wide apartment prices have now risen for 92 consecutive weeks.

Seongdong-gu and Gangdong-gu have recently turned negative, and Dongjak-gu has gone flat, suggesting that areas adjacent to the Gangnam core are also beginning to face downward pressure. Even so, prices in outlying areas — particularly those along the so-called semiconductor belt, where major chipmakers including Samsung Electronics and SK hynix have concentrated their production facilities — are rising sharply. Apartment prices in Yongin and Suwon jumped 3.38% and 5.02%, respectively, over the same period, while Hwaseong rose 3.4%.

Compared with 2018, the pace of gains in Seoul's non-prime districts is gradually slowing, but key Gyeonggi Province cities are posting even higher rates of increase, raising the prospect that prime areas such as Gangnam could eventually be pulled upward as well.

Adding to that pressure, semiconductor-sector bonuses and other performance pay set to flow from next year could stoke demand for home purchases. A report the Bank of Korea released in August found that in Icheon, Gyeonggi Province, income gains from SK hynix bonus payments translated disproportionately into housing-related spending.

Experts generally see little chance of a sharp move — up or down — in prime areas for the time being.

Lee Eun-hyung, a research fellow at the Korea Construction Policy Research Institute, said it is difficult to read a few weeks of declines in Gangnam as an inflection point toward a sustained downturn. "Some listings are coming to market at lower prices in high-value areas to get ahead of the tax reform, which is set to raise property holding taxes and take effect next year," Lee said, adding that the trend in outlying areas suggests prices will not fall further for now.

Ham Young-jin, head of the real estate research lab at Woori Bank, said a shortage of new apartment supply in Seoul next year would support a floor under prices through the rental market. "Demand in Gangnam will be concentrated in distressed listings, but interest rates, price fatigue, government regulation and tax reform will all be significant hurdles," Ham said.

If Gangnam prices show signs of rebounding as they did in 2018, the Bank of Korea's tightening stance is expected to harden further. Bank of Korea Governor Shin Hyun-song has maintained that monetary policy alone has limits in curbing home prices, but he has emphasized the stabilizing effect of rate hikes on real estate. After raising the benchmark interest rate twice in consecutive meetings in August, Shin told reporters at a press briefing that the preemptive rate increases would "help at least somewhat in easing the steep rise in housing prices."

The Bank of Korea holds its final monetary policy meeting of the year on Nov. 26, when it will set the benchmark interest rate. Markets widely expect a 0.25 percentage point increase, which would bring the rate to 3.25%.


kimstar@heraldcorp.com