Dispute over first-instance ruling on shareholder meeting resolution
Korea Zinc says plaintiffs' arguments being presented as court findings
Company cites gap with Supreme Court injunction ruling, confirms appeal
Korea Zinc wins appeal in separate new-share issuance case Thursday
Korea Zinc fired back Monday at MBK Partners and Youngpoong, accusing them of distorting a first-instance court ruling in the lawsuit over the cancellation of resolutions passed at its annual general meeting and waging a media campaign by presenting the plaintiffs' own arguments as the court's official findings. Korea Zinc said the ruling conflicts with established Supreme Court precedent and vowed to contest its legal validity in the appeals process.
Korea Zinc issued a statement Monday saying MBK and Youngpoong were broadly interpreting the first-instance ruling in their favor. The company said the two parties were causing confusion in the market by presenting content explicitly described in the ruling as the plaintiffs' arguments as if it were the court's official determination.
The Seoul Central District Court's Civil Division 29 ruled Thursday in favor of Youngpoong and MBK in their lawsuit against Korea Zinc seeking to cancel resolutions passed at last year's annual general meeting. The court found that Korea Zinc had improperly restricted the voting rights of its largest shareholder, Youngpoong, at the March last year meeting, citing a cross-shareholding relationship as the basis.
A cross-shareholding relationship refers to two companies each holding shares in the other. The Commercial Act restricts the exercise of voting rights in cross-shareholding arrangements that meet certain conditions. Korea Zinc established such a relationship last year when its Australian subsidiary Sun Metals Holdings (SMH) received shares in Youngpoong held by its sub-subsidiary Sun Metals Corporation (SMC) as a dividend in kind, and on that basis restricted Youngpoong's voting rights at the annual general meeting.
The first-instance court found that the cross-shareholding provisions could not be used to restrict an existing shareholder's voting rights for the purpose of defending management control. Korea Zinc, however, maintains that once a cross-shareholding relationship is legally established, its effect on voting rights should not be assessed differently simply because a management control dispute is under way.
Korea Zinc is basing its appeal on existing Supreme Court precedent and the outcome of an injunction case finalized in April this year. Notably, the Supreme Court ruled in 2001 that the cross-shareholding voting restriction regime can function as a defensive mechanism to prevent one company from dominating another and to promote management stability.
Korea Zinc's position also prevailed in the injunction proceedings over voting rights at last year's annual general meeting. The Supreme Court rejected Youngpoong's further appeal in April and upheld the lower court's decision.
The lower court in that case found it difficult to conclude that Korea Zinc's management had committed breach of fiduciary duty or violated the Fair Trade Act in acquiring Youngpoong shares through overseas affiliates for personal gain. It also found no basis for a capital markets law violation in the process by which SMC distributed its Youngpoong shares to SMH as a dividend in kind.
Korea Zinc said that because no new facts have emerged in the main lawsuit since the injunction proceedings, it believes it can adequately argue the discrepancy with the earlier ruling before a higher court.
Korea Zinc also said the ruling has not yet been finalized. Because a ruling canceling shareholder meeting resolutions takes effect only upon finalization, the existing resolutions remain in force while the appeal and subsequent proceedings continue, the company said.
Youngpoong and MBK welcomed the first-instance ruling, saying it confirmed that Korea Zinc's restrictions on voting rights could not be justified. They argued that the legitimacy of the amendments to the articles of incorporation and the election of directors and audit committee members at last year's annual general meeting were called into question.
The dispute began in September 2024, when Youngpoong joined forces with private equity fund manager MBK Partners in a bid to seize management control of Korea Zinc. The conflict has since dragged on through a tender offer, a proxy battle at a shareholder meeting, and a series of lawsuits.
Korea Zinc also cited a separate court finding that Youngpoong and MBK's bid for management control was perceived as a threat to the company. A ruling by the Seoul Central District Court last month found that Youngpoong's coordination with outside party MBK Partners in an attempt to take control of Korea Zinc's board was recognized as a threat by that board, the company said.
Korea Zinc also pointed to opposition from labor and civic groups. Since the management control dispute began in 2024, labor organizations and civic groups in Ulsan have repeatedly voiced opposition to Youngpoong and MBK's takeover attempt.
Meanwhile, a separate case between Korea Zinc and Youngpoong produced the opposite result. The Seoul High Court on Thursday overturned a first-instance ruling in Youngpoong's appeal against Korea Zinc over the invalidation of a new share issuance, siding with Korea Zinc. The court found that a third-party allotment capital increase carried out in 2023 targeting HMG Global, a US joint venture of Hyundai Motor Group, was conducted for legitimate business purposes and could not be deemed invalid.
"We will continue to respond to any distortion of court rulings or the spread of claims that differ from the facts," Korea Zinc said. "In addition, we will continue our existing projects, including securing critical mineral supply chains and enhancing corporate value."
kwater@heraldcorp.com
