On-site oversight proves vulnerable to high-tech cheating
AI misconduct in skilled-trades exam drew a fine in February, yet tax accountant exams went undetected until a confession
Fragmented oversight and weak post-exam verification prompt government-wide audit
The revelation that the top scorer on this year's tax accountant licensing exam used generative AI to cheat has drawn fire over the lax oversight of national licensing exams. Proctors monitoring the exam floor at close range failed to detect cheating carried out with a miniature camera. Critics say visual-only supervision is no longer sufficient against increasingly sophisticated misconduct, and that the system for verifying and penalizing cheating after an exam concludes is equally inadequate.
According to related ministries, Han, who topped the 63rd tax accountant exam, appeared on a YouTube channel Sunday and admitted to photographing exam questions with a miniature camera, transmitting them to an AI and checking the answers on a smartphone. Han scored 397.5 out of 400 on the first-stage exam in April and 663 out of 800 on the second-stage exam in July — including a perfect score on the tax law section, where the average candidate scored in the 30s. Despite the extraordinary results raising suspicions, Han denied any wrongdoing before ultimately confessing and submitting a voluntary surrender statement to the Seoul Metropolitan Police Agency. Han also stated that the same method was used on the certified public accountant first-stage exam.
On the day of the tax accountant exam, candidates were instructed to power off their mobile phones and place them in their bags, but there was no separate procedure to check for wearable electronic devices such as miniature cameras. Han sat in the second row from the front during the first-stage exam and in the first row during the second-stage exam. Both exam rooms had two proctors each, yet neither detected any misconduct. The Human Resources Development Service of Korea said it confirmed with all four proctors that they had noticed nothing suspicious at the time.
This was not the first time AI-assisted cheating had come to light. A candidate who used AI to check answers during a skilled-trades written exam administered by the Human Resources Development Service of Korea was handed a fine in February. Despite that similar method having already been caught, the same type of cheating went undetected at the tax accountant exams held in April and July.
Mismanagement of national licensing exams has long extended beyond AI cheating enforcement.
In July, an exam booklet for a general mechanical engineer practical exam was opened a day early, forcing 57 candidates to retake the test. After that incident, the agency pledged to review the entire process from question-setting through administration, grading and results announcement — yet on Nov. 1, a video file error during a biological classification engineer practical exam forced 120 candidates to retake the video portion. A question on the Oct. 25 electrical engineer practical exam was also flagged as containing an error in a five-point item.
Similar incidents have occurred in the past. In 2023, answer sheets for 609 candidates in engineer and industrial engineer practical exams were shredded before grading, and four more were lost, sending 566 candidates to retake the test. Last year, a computer grading error in the first-stage certified labor attorney exam led to five candidates being announced as having passed before the results were rescinded. The Ministry of Employment and Labor had previously issued institutional warnings to the agency over both the shredding and the grading error. Two consecutive former presidents of the Human Resources Development Service of Korea left office before completing their terms due to mismanagement of national licensing exams.
Cheong Wa Dae convened an emergency response meeting Sunday, chaired by Policy Chief Ha Jun-kyung, and decided to conduct a comprehensive audit of all national licensing exams.
The Ministry of Employment and Labor plans to review answer sheets from this year's exams for suspicious cases, prioritizing those with unusually high scores, and will open both online and offline tip-off centers. The agency will pursue an expansion of AI inspectors and the introduction of radio-frequency detectors. Han's exam results will be invalidated and a five-year bar on sitting for exams will be pursued. The Ministry of Economy and Finance said it is discussing suspending the validity of Han's license certificate.
The fragmented distribution of exam oversight and investigative responsibility across agencies is also a concern. The Human Resources Development Service of Korea administers 37 licensing exams on behalf of 17 government ministries, including the tax accountant exam — but the certified public accountant exam, which Han stated was also taken using the same method, falls under the Financial Services Commission, with related operations handled by the Financial Supervisory Service. Han is understood to have failed that exam. The publicly announced response measures did not address which agency would investigate exams not administered by the agency, or by what standard candidates who failed would be scrutinized.
Under the Tax Accountant Act, the minister of economy and finance may invalidate a cheater's exam results and bar the individual from sitting for five years. However, applying that provision requires proving that an electronic device was actually used to cheat. Mere possession alone is not sufficient grounds for sanctions, and there are also legal limits on conducting compulsory searches of candidates' belongings without reasonable suspicion.
Proving cheating after an exam has already concluded also hinges on how much contemporaneous documentation — such as proctoring logs and on-site incident reports — can be secured. The Suneung college entrance exam, scheduled for Thursday, carries the same concerns. Under current procedures, candidates deposit their mobile phones and other electronic devices in collection boxes themselves, and proctors do not separately inspect belongings.
fact0514@heraldcorp.com
