Union leadership faces criminal referral over alleged trade-secret leak; court bars strikes at 9 key production processes; membership shrinks amid dues backlash and strike fatigue
The Samsung Biologics Mutual Prosperity Labor Union finds itself cornered on all sides as legal, internal and external setbacks converge at once.
With a court order barring strikes at nine core production processes, the union's second walkout has been reduced to a partial strike. The union's leadership is now under fresh pressure after police referred its top two officials to prosecutors on charges of leaking confidential company documents.
Internal cohesion is fraying further as members grow disillusioned with a strike seen as yielding little and resist a mandatory strike-fund levy. Backed into a corner, the union is pushing ahead with a membership vote on joining the Federation of Korean Trade Unions as it heads into a resumption of wage and collective bargaining negotiations on Tuesday.
Court halts strikes at 9 processes; union chiefs referred to prosecutors over alleged trade-secret leak
The most serious threat facing the union is the accumulation of legal constraints. The First Civil Division of the Seoul High Court's Incheon bench ruled on Oct. 16, in an appeal of the company's injunction application, that all nine core production processes — from cell culture through filling — qualify as "security operations" under the Trade Union and Labor Relations Adjustment Act. The court barred any industrial action that disrupts the normal operation of those processes, effectively blocking a full strike aimed at shutting down the main production lines.
Then on Wednesday, the Incheon Metropolitan Police Agency referred union Chairman Park Jae-sung and organizational director Lee Nam-hun to prosecutors, recommending indictment on charges of violating the Unfair Competition Prevention and Trade Secret Protection Act, occupational breach of trust, and defamation through false statements. The two are accused of taking unauthorized screenshots of tax invoice records from the company's public relations department via the internal enterprise resource planning system and distributing them externally.
Prosecutors have yet to decide whether to indict, and no final judicial ruling has been issued. Police concluded there was sufficient cause for charges after conducting a forced investigation that included a search and seizure at the Songdo plant, converting the union leadership into suspects. In a separate development, prosecutors recently overturned a police decision not to refer a union member who allegedly entered production areas without authorization during the first strike in May to monitor operations, ordering a reinvestigation. The move has placed the union's entire approach to industrial action under scrutiny from law enforcement.
'We never distributed it' — denial under fire; dues backlash accelerates membership exodus
Questions about the leadership's integrity, compounded by strike fatigue, are rapidly eroding internal unity. Immediately after the police referral, the union issued a statement rebuffing the decision: "We cannot accept the judgment that raising questions about promotional spending constitutes a trade-secret violation. The chairman never distributed the materials externally and derived no personal benefit."
The denial has itself become a source of controversy. When the leak allegations first surfaced, Park had flatly denied in a group chat with union members that he had ever distributed the documents — a claim now back under scrutiny.
The leadership's credibility had already taken a hit during the first strike when it emerged that Park had taken personal leave. Membership has since fallen to around 3,000 as workers pushed back against wage losses under the no-work-no-pay principle and a mandatory strike-fund levy of 200,000 to 300,000 won ($225) per person. The legal jeopardy now facing the leadership is seen as accelerating the internal drift.
Indirect-department strike causes zero production disruption; union loses its leverage
The union's external bargaining leverage has also weakened considerably. Blocked from striking at core production processes, the union pivoted on Nov. 6 to a three-week partial strike centered on indirect departments — quality control, quality assurance and logistics.
The move backfired when the union sent an email to company quality executives on Sunday warning that it would report any quality-standard violations to regulators. Critics said the message amounted to the union itself creating a strike-induced gap in oversight and then shifting the blame to management.
Meanwhile, the company has kept its production lines running without disruption. Samsung Biologics also wrapped up fundraising for the acquisition of Swiss firm PolyPeptide Group, drawing a record 11.44 trillion won in subscription deposits in its general public offering at a competition ratio of 135.6-to-1, following a 96.8 percent take-up rate among existing shareholders in its 2.67 trillion won ($2 billion) rights offering — a show of investor confidence that underscored the company's steady footing.
FKTU membership vote and Tuesday talks seen as pivotal moment for union's exit strategy
Cornered, the union leadership has abandoned the apolitical, independent stance it championed at its founding and is now seeking affiliation with the Federation of Korean Trade Unions (FKTU). The union, which broke away from Samsung Group's cross-enterprise union in June, began a membership vote on FKTU affiliation Saturday at 9 a.m. and will run it through next Wednesday at 9 a.m.
Against that backdrop, the two sides are set to resume wage and collective bargaining negotiations on Tuesday — two weeks after talks originally scheduled for Nov. 3 were postponed over the union's credibility issues.
Industry observers expect Tuesday's session, which opens one day before the vote closes, to serve as a critical juncture at which the union leadership may seek an exit from the prolonged strike rather than dig in further. Samsung Biologics said it remains fully committed to maintaining quality and process stability, and that its willingness to reach an amicable agreement through dialogue is unchanged.
silverpaper@heraldcorp.com
